You called it a stretch target. A leader presents a steep target chart to her leadership team.

7-DAY PRACTICE · OPTIMISM AND REALISM

From Chapter 17 of Leadership Drift · 5-minute read, 2 minutes a day

Ask What Would Have to Be True: the 2-minute version from Wednesday's email

  1. Take your boldest target for next year.

  2. Ask: what would have to be true for this to happen? List every answer.

  3. Mark each one: we know this, we hope this, or we haven't checked.

Why this works

Over-optimism rarely starts as a decision. It starts as a wish to protect the room: to keep morale up, prevent panic, and hold confidence when others are anxious. Little by little, hope starts editing reality.

Asking what would have to be true moves the conversation from belief to evidence, without anyone having to say the target is wrong. It turns doubt that lives in the corridor into assumptions you can look at together.

It matters because a plan the team doesn't believe still gets executed, just half-heartedly, with the explanations already prepared. People trust a leader's hope far more once they have seen that leader look honestly at the difficulty.

❝

We will not use hope to avoid truth; we will use truth to build better hope.

Leadership Drift, Chapter 17

Five signs your plan is running on hope

If you see two or more of these, the room knows something the plan doesn't.

The sign

What it often means

Ask

The room goes quiet after the number

People disagree but won't say so

"What are we not saying because we want to stay positive?"

The real debate happens after the meeting

Doubt has gone underground

"What would make you less confident in this?"

Bad news arrives already softened

People expect you to reframe it

"Let's stay with what this is telling us first."

Lots of "should", "hopefully" and "stretch"

Confidence without a basis

"What exactly is our confidence based on?"

Plan B is only discussed privately

The team has a forecast, and it isn't yours

"What's our plan if this assumption is wrong?"

The 7 days

DAY 1 Ask the question. Take your biggest number and list what would have to be true. Mark each answer: know, hope, or haven't checked.

DAY 2 Pause before you reframe. When bad news arrives, wait. Ask "What exactly is this telling us?" before you move to solutions.

DAY 3 Invite the concern. In one meeting, ask the question that makes doubt welcome:

"What are we not saying because we want to stay positive?"

DAY 4 Test your hope. Ask what your confidence is based on: a capability, a decision, a resource, a relationship, a real opportunity. If it rests on none of these, say so.

DAY 5 Check one assumption. Pick one "we hope this" and test it, with data or with the person closest to the work.

DAY 6 Review hope and facts together. With your team, answer three questions: What are the facts we must face? What can we still influence? What message would carry both truth and credible hope?

DAY 7 Rewrite the message. Say it in two sentences: one about the reality, one about what you can do. For example:

"We can be honest about the difficulty and still believe in our ability to respond."

If you're the opposite: the one who always says why it won't work

Some leaders have the opposite problem. Under pressure, they meet every idea with its risks. They believe they are keeping the team grounded, but people stop bringing ambitions at all, and the room becomes accurate but flat.

The practice: when an idea comes up, ask "What would make this worth exploring?" before "What could go wrong?" And whenever you name a serious risk, follow it with "What can we influence from here?"

Where does pressure pull you most?

The free Window of Equilibrium Index maps all 12 tensions: where you lead from, where you drift under pressure, and how quickly you come back. Chapter 17 of Leadership Drift covers this tension in full, including a five-question review for moments of real uncertainty.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate